Claude + MCP Tools Plus vs ChatGPT + MCP Tools Plus: Which AI Assistant to Run Your PrestaShop Store in 2026?

In 2026, Artificial Intelligence isn't just a buzzword; it's an indispensable operational co-pilot for thriving e-commerce businesses. Yet, a crucial question frequently arises in my discussions with PrestaShop store owners:

"Should I choose Claude or ChatGPT to empower my online shop?"

The straightforward answer? It largely depends on your specific operational needs.

Having the distinct (and somewhat demanding) opportunity to leverage both platforms daily, integrated through the same powerful module — MCP Tools Plus for PrestaShop, I embarked on a mission to deliver a definitive verdict.

This isn't about theoretical musings or abstract benchmarks.
It's about a real store, actual products, and authentic e-commerce challenges.

The Experiment's Design

The Retail Environment

My testbed was a genuine PrestaShop 8.x installation, mirroring the complexities of real-world retail:

• Approximately 1,200 active products (primarily fashion & accessories)
• Three years of comprehensive order history
• Multi-warehouse stock management fully operational
• Disorderly, incomplete data – a truly authentic scenario

The Unified Link

Both AI assistants leveraged an identical access point: MCP Tools Plus. This module, which I developed, exposes PrestaShop's internal data via the Model Context Protocol (MCP).

Same API. Same data streams. Identical permissions.

Only the underlying AI intelligence shifted.

The Five Crucial Trials

CONTEST 1 — Quarterly Sales Performance Deep Dive

The Directive

"Analyze my sales figures from the last quarter. Highlight emerging trends, top-performing items, underperformers, and offer three actionable recommendations."

Claude (Anthropic) in Action

Claude initiated its process by seeking clarification:

"By 'last quarter,' do you mean Q1 2026 (January-March)? And should I include canceled orders, or focus solely on validated transactions?"

After retrieving the necessary data via MCP Tools Plus, it delivered a multi-layered analysis:

• Overall Financial View: Total revenue, average order value, and quarter-over-quarter growth against Q4 2025.
• Product Performance: Identification of the top 10 and bottom 10 products, crucially factoring in margins, not just raw revenue.
• Customer Behavior Insights: Analysis of peak sales days and correlations with previous marketing efforts.
• Strategic Advice: Precise, nuanced suggestions, often accompanied by cautionary notes like "however, proceed with care regarding..."

A noteworthy observation: Claude independently cross-referenced sales statistics with current stock levels, alerting me that three top-selling items were nearing depletion. This proactive insight was entirely unprompted.

ChatGPT (OpenAI) in Action

ChatGPT immediately sprang into action. Without any preliminary questions, it retrieved the data and promptly generated a visually appealing report:

• Neatly formatted tables enriched with emojis and a polished aesthetic.
• Text-based charts providing an ASCII representation of trends.
• A decidedly "consultant-like" tone: impactful phrases, concise bullet points, and bolded key figures.
• More assertive recommendations: "Discontinue these 5 SKUs," "Double the inventory for product X."

A noteworthy observation: Its sheer speed and immediate clarity were striking. The report was instantly "client-ready" for a sales director.

Verdict for Contest 1

Claude emerged victorious in this round. Its unparalleled capacity to integrate unrequested data and present finely-tuned conclusions set it apart. While ChatGPT offered a more "flashy" presentation, Claude delivered superior substance.

CONTEST 2 — Inventory Depletion Prediction & Management

The Directive

"Pinpoint products at risk of going out of stock within the next 15 days and propose a replenishment strategy."

Claude in Action

Claude systematically dissected the challenge:

1. Retrieved current inventory levels via MCP Tools Plus.
2. Calculated the sales velocity for each product over the past 30 days.
3. Projected potential stockouts by dividing current stock by daily sales velocity.
4. Prioritized items by urgency (e.g., stockout in 3 days vs. 12 days).
5. Suggested restocking quantities, incorporating supplier lead times (and requesting them if missing).

The outcome: A prioritized replenishment schedule that included an "estimated revenue impact if stockout occurs" column.

An unexpected bonus: Claude flagged two products with negative stock counts (indicating a data error) and advised an immediate audit.

ChatGPT in Action

ChatGPT adopted a more direct, immediate response strategy:

1. Fetched current stock and recent sales data.
2. Generated an alert roster with clear color coding.
3. Provided instant directives: "Place an order for 50 units of REF-4521 today."
4. Advocated for automating similar alerts for future proactive management.

Its methodology leaned towards "act now" rather than "comprehensively analyze." ChatGPT’s aim was to instigate immediate action.

Verdict for Contest 2

Claude secured another win, primarily due to its in-depth analytical approach. However, ChatGPT scored valuable points for its emphasis on swift, decisive action.

CONTEST 3 — Product Description Generation

The Directive

"Recreate the descriptions for these five summer dresses, optimizing for SEO. The tone should be elegant yet approachable. Target audience: women aged 28-45. Integrate technical specifications from the PrestaShop listing."

Claude in Action

Claude retrieved the product listings via MCP Tools Plus and crafted descriptions that were remarkably... human-like.

• Each description showcased a distinct narrative style (avoiding repetitive templates).
• It seamlessly integrated SEO keywords without compromising natural flow.
• The tone was subtly adjusted for each item: more relaxed for a linen dress, more refined for an evening gown.
• It infused sensory micro-details: "The piqué cotton breathes effortlessly, even on the warmest days."

A powerful advantage: Claude spontaneously provided optimized meta title and meta description suggestions, further aiding SEO.

ChatGPT in Action

ChatGPT delivered descriptions that were technically superb for SEO:

• Included a recommended H2/H3 heading structure.
• Maintained excellent keyword density control.
• Each description featured an embedded call-to-action.
• The format resembled a "professional product data sheet" more than a narrative piece.
• It even suggested A/B testing variants for optimizing conversions.

A powerful advantage: ChatGPT simultaneously generated product FAQ suggestions (akin to "People Also Ask" sections) to significantly enhance SEO visibility.

Verdict for Contest 3

A very close call, with a slight edge to ChatGPT. If your primary goal is pure SEO optimization, ChatGPT is exceptionally potent. However, if your aim is compelling copy that genuinely motivates purchases (driving conversion), Claude presented a clear editorial superiority.

CONTEST 4 — Operational Problem Diagnosis

The Directive

"My conversion rate dropped by 15% this month. Help me understand why by analyzing the available data."

Claude in Action

This is undeniably where Claude outperformed the competition.

Its methodology mirrored that of a seasoned consultant:

1. "Before diving into causes, let me first confirm if this drop is statistically significant and not simply a seasonal anomaly." — It compared figures against the same period in the previous year.
2. Segmented the decline by traffic source (if this data was present in order records).
3. Cross-referenced for out-of-stock popular products (examining stock/conversion correlation).
4. Analyzed the average basket value: Was the drop due to fewer orders or lower order values?
5. Searched for temporal correlations: Did the decline coincide with any price adjustments or the conclusion of a promotional campaign?

Claude’s test conclusion:

"The observed drop appears primarily linked to the stock depletion of three best-selling items since the 8th of the month, coupled with the end of your 20% discount campaign on the 5th. This decline is circumstantial, not structural. Recommendation: prioritize restocking REF-2847 and REF-3391, and launch a targeted offer specifically for returning visitors."

ChatGPT in Action

ChatGPT presented a well-structured inventory of potential causes:

• Technical glitches (site loading speed, 404 errors)
• Price fluctuations
• Inventory shortages
• Seasonal variations
• Competitive pressures

While relevant, its approach was more generalized. ChatGPT provided a list of hypotheses, whereas Claude prioritized and validated explanations using real-time data.

Verdict for Contest 4

Claude demonstrated clear dominance. Its natural strength lies in multi-step reasoning applied to interwoven data sets.

CONTEST 5 — Fully Autonomous Workflow

The Directive

"Conduct a thorough audit of my store: identify all issues, propose solutions, and implement any risk-free corrections automatically."

This represented the ultimate challenge – tasking the AI with chaining analysis, decision-making, and direct action.

Claude in Action

Claude excelled in the analytical and recommendation phases. It identified:

• 47 products lacking descriptions.
• 12 products incorrectly priced at 0 euros.
• 8 categories missing meta descriptions.
• 3 products with absent images.

However – and this is a hallmark of Claude’s design – it exercised prudence in execution:

"I am able to correct the missing category meta descriptions and populate empty product descriptions. For the products priced at 0 euros, I recommend you manually validate each correction, as pricing errors can have direct financial repercussions. Here is a list with my suggested prices based on comparable products in your catalog."

Claude only proceeded with what was unequivocally safe. For anything with potential financial impact, it sought validation. This cautious approach instilled confidence.

ChatGPT in Action

ChatGPT adopted a more assertive stance:

"I’ve identified 70 issues. I have already resolved 34 of these (including empty descriptions, meta descriptions, and missing attributes). For the remaining 36, here are my proposed actions..."

ChatGPT acted first, then reported. This approach offered greater speed but necessitated a higher degree of trust in the tool’s autonomy.

Verdict for Contest 5

ChatGPT won this round if the priority is operational velocity. Claude prevailed if the goal is absolute peace of mind and error prevention.

The Final Performance Overview

Overall Score: Claude 92 — ChatGPT 76

My Pragmatic Recommendation

I’ll forgo the typical "it depends on your situation" cliché. Instead, I offer a more precise guide:

Opt for Claude + MCP Tools Plus if:

• You oversee an intricate product catalog (featuring numerous combinations, multiple warehouses).
• You desire an assistant that deeply analyzes before acting.
• You require profound analytical insights for strategic business decisions.
• Data integrity and the accuracy of conclusions are your paramount concerns.
• You manage your store independently and simply cannot afford costly errors.

Opt for ChatGPT + MCP Tools Plus if:

• You frequently need content at scale (product descriptions, SEO elements, translations).
• You prefer an assistant that executes tasks rapidly with minimal oversight.
• You generate reports for external stakeholders (prioritizing immediate clarity).
• You are comfortable with a workflow that includes reviewing and refining AI-generated outputs.
• You have a team capable of validating the AI's actions.

Or, Consider a Hybrid Approach: Use Both!

This isn't a jest. With MCP Tools Plus, the same module seamlessly connects both AI models. The incremental cost is virtually negligible.

My personal operational strategy involves:

• Claude for in-depth analysis, diagnostics, and strategic planning.
• ChatGPT for high-volume execution, content generation, and routine tasks.

It's truly the best of both intelligent worlds.

The Profound Truth This Experiment Reveals

Beyond the direct face-off between Claude and ChatGPT, this comparison unveils a fundamental insight:

Integrating Generative AI with your actual business data transforms everything.

Without MCP Tools Plus, Claude and ChatGPT function as sophisticated chatbots, merely speculating about your business operations.

With MCP Tools Plus, they evolve into indispensable operational collaborators, actively working with your genuine data, real products, and live orders.

This crucial connection is the true differentiator, far more than the specific AI model itself.

How MCP Tools Plus Empowers This Integration

For those curious about the technical mechanism allowing both AIs to access the same data, here's an overview of what the module exposes via the MCP protocol:

• Comprehensive Product Catalog: Detailed information on products, combinations, pricing, stock levels, images, and descriptions.
• Order and Transaction History: Full order details, statuses, and associated customer information.
• Performance Analytics: Sales data categorized by period, category, and individual product.
• Category Management: The complete category tree structure, SEO metadata, and product associations.
• Customer Data: Customer segments, purchase histories, and abandoned cart details.
• Direct Write Actions: Capabilities for updating stock, prices, descriptions, and order statuses.

Explore all features and capabilities: nicolas-dabene.fr/modules/mcp-tools-plus/

The Enduring Question

This comparison offers a snapshot in time. Both platforms are evolving at a breakneck pace, with Claude 4 and GPT-5 anticipated to bring further advancements.

Yet, one fundamental truth will remain constant: the ultimate value originates from the symbiotic connection to your data, not from the AI model in isolation.

And that, precisely, is the pivotal role of MCP Tools Plus.

So, are you Team Claude or Team ChatGPT? Share your thoughts in the comments below! And if you're already leveraging MCP Tools Plus with either, I'd love to hear about your experiences.

---

Nicolas Dabène — Creator of MCP Tools Plus for PrestaShop & firmly convinced that the future of e-commerce unfolds at the intersection of AI and your unique business data.

---

Ready to dive deeper into the world of e-commerce AI and PrestaShop?

Don't miss out on more insights, tips, and tutorials! Join my community and connect with me:

➡️ Subscribe to my YouTube channel: youtube.com/@ndabene06 for video walkthroughs and expert advice.
➡️ Connect with me on LinkedIn: fr.linkedin.com/in/nicolas-dabène-473a43b8 to stay updated on the latest in e-commerce and AI innovation.